Occam's razor wins again

One of Anthropic's LLMs figured out how NIST generated the curves that are part of FIPS 186-2 the ECDSA standard. Turns out it was a generic PRNG seeded with a unix timestamp.

Anthropic announced that one of their LLMs "cracked" the origin of the curves that are part of FIPS 186-2. Specifically, the curves P-192, P-224, P-256, P-384, P-512, as well as the binary curves that aren't really used anywhere.

What Anthropic discovered was that the parameters for all of these curves were created using the output from lrand48, seeded with a unix timestamp of somewhere around 1997.

That's a pretty boring outcome to what has otherwise been a somewhat spicy conspiracy theory: that the NSA picked the NIST curves, such that they contained some sort of hidden backdoor.

Turns out that the simplest possible explanation was the correct one. A random number was needed (the seed), and thus a standard random number generator was invoked (lrand48).

Anyways

The NIST elliptic seeds bounty has been claimed by Anthropic, but they donated the money to the ISRG. That's probably strategic, given that their LLMs keep commiting computer crimes (maybe they feel bad? lol).

Filippo Valsorda also has a decent writeup on this whole thing. Definitely also worth a read. As is the original post by Anthropic for that matter.


CC BY-SA

Published: 2026-10-17